Supplier comparison
Octopus Energy vs Utilita: prepayment, prices, service and switching
Edited by Rob Gibbs. Published: . Guidance reviewed: .
Quick answer: Octopus or Utilita?
Utilita is a smart pay-as-you-go specialist. Its Smart Energy tariff has no standing charge, using two unit rates instead, and it offers emergency and friendly credit and high-street Energy Hubs.
If you can pay by Direct Debit, Octopus’s tariffs will usually work out cheaper, and its smart tariffs and export rate go far beyond what Utilita offers.
Utilita sits near the bottom of the Citizens Advice table and is under open Ofgem investigation over prepayment meters.
Octopus vs Utilita side by side
| Category | Octopus Energy | Utilita |
|---|---|---|
| Standard tariff | Flexible Octopus, no exit fee | Smart Energy: pay as you go, no standing charge, two unit rates, no exit fee |
| Fixed deals | 12M and 18M Fixed, with exit fees (see the quotes below) | None found |
| Off-peak tariff | Intelligent Go: 6 whole-home hours from 23:30 plus smart charging for supported cars. Go: 00:30–05:30 for any EV | Smart E7: cheaper night rate on pay as you go |
| Heat pump and battery tariffs | Cosy: cheap 04:00–07:00, 13:00–16:00 and 22:00–00:00. Flux. Intelligent Flux only if you bought your solar and battery from Octopus | None |
| Solar export | Outgoing Octopus fixed rate or half-hourly Outgoing Agile; needs an Octopus import tariff | 3p/kWh, no supply needed |
| Prepayment support | Octopus also supplies prepayment meters | Emergency credit up to £15, friendly credit hours, POWER UP temporary credit up to £25 per fuel |
| Size | Over 8 million UK customers, about 26% of homes | About 800,000 customers (2025); sold 40,000 credit customers to EDF |
| Ofgem | £1.5m (July 2025) for late final bills to prepayment customers | Open investigations into prepayment meters (since November 2024) and energy theft; £277,000 Warm Home Discount redress (June 2025) |
Is Octopus cheaper than Utilita?
Every supplier’s standard variable tariff is held to the Ofgem price cap. From 1 October to 31 December 2026 the cap works out at £1,723 a year for a typical dual-fuel home paying by Direct Debit: on average 26.32p/kWh for electricity plus 54.83p a day, and 7.97p/kWh for gas plus 29.68p a day. There is no VAT on electricity until 31 March 2027. Ofgem announces the January to March 2027 cap by 25 November.
Pay-as-you-go tariffs have their own cap. On pay as you go, Utilita’s Smart Energy tariff replaces the standing charge with two unit rates, which can suit very low users but costs more per kWh as you use more.
The quotes below are Direct Debit prices for the same address and usage, so Utilita’s quote there includes a standing charge.
Octopus vs Utilita: tariff by tariff
Every dual-fuel tariff both suppliers are selling this month, quoted for the same address on 2026-11-01: monthly Direct Debit and 2,500 kWh of electricity and 9,500 kWh of gas a year. Cheapest first; rates include VAT.
- Cheapest variable or tracker: Flexible Octopus at £1,664 against Smart Energy at £1,672. Octopus is £8 a year cheaper.
| Tariff | Type | Electricity unit / day | Gas unit / day | Exit fee | Annual cost |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| OctopusFlexible Octopus | Variable | 25.36p/kWh, 50.20p/day | 7.82p/kWh, 28.45p/day | None | £1,664 |
| UtilitaSmart Energy | Variable | 25.35p/kWh, 51.44p/day | 7.82p/kWh, 29.40p/day | None | £1,672 |
| OctopusOctopus 18M Fixed October 2026 v7 | Fixed, 18 months | 27.50p/kWh, 50.20p/day | 9.20p/kWh, 28.46p/day | £150 | £1,848 |
| OctopusOctopus 12M Fixed October 2026 v8 | Fixed, 12 months | 28.90p/kWh, 50.20p/day | 9.36p/kWh, 28.46p/day | £100 | £1,899 |
Exit fees are the total for both fuels. Your own prices depend on your region and usage, so use these to compare the shape of each tariff and get a postcode quote before switching. A fix that costs more than a variable tariff today can still pay off if the price cap rises during the fix.
Utilita’s pay-as-you-go tariffs are held to the prepayment price cap for your region. Octopus Flexible on Direct Debit is held to the Direct Debit cap.
Octopus rates today in London
| What you pay | Octopus in London today | Utilita |
|---|---|---|
| Standard variable unit rate | 26.60p/kWh on Flexible, 41.39p/day standing charge | Capped at the regional Ofgem limit. Utilita quotes its own rate for your postcode. |
| EV off-peak rate | 9.40p/kWh on Go | No published EV rate |
| Solar export payment | 12.00p/kWh on Outgoing Octopus | 3p/kWh on Utilita SEG (Utilita: our schemes, checked 2026-11-05) |
Customer service and complaints
Utilita offers face-to-face help in its Energy Hubs, but its independent scores are among the lowest we track, and Ofgem has two investigations open into the company.
Citizens Advice ranks Octopus 5th and Utilita 15th for April to June 2026. On the measures below, Octopus comes out ahead on 5 and Utilita on 2.
| Measure | Octopus Energy | Utilita |
|---|---|---|
| Citizens Advice rating | 3.67 / 5 (5th) | 2.53 / 5 (15th) |
| Complaints to Citizens Advice per 10,000 customers | 21.4 | 95.7 |
| Average call wait | 1m 9s | 0m 5s |
| Complaints received per 100,000 accounts | 476 (Q2 2026) | 946 (Q2 2026) |
| Complaints resolved within 8 weeks | 80% | 93% |
| Which? customer score | 74% | 68% |
| Trustpilot | 4.8 / 5 from 911,202 reviews | 4.3 / 5 from 113,129 reviews |
| App rating (App Store / Google Play) | 4.8 / 4.3 | 4.4 / 4.1 |
Better figure in bold. Collected 2026-11 from Citizens Advice, the suppliers' own Ofgem-format complaints reports, the Which? energy survey, Trustpilot and the app stores. Trustpilot and app ratings are self-selected reviews; the Citizens Advice and complaints figures are the more reliable guide.
Utilita smart, EV and export tariffs
| Utilita product | What it offers | Nearest Octopus option |
|---|---|---|
| Smart EnergyTime of use | Smart pay as you go with no standing charge and two unit rates. No exit fee. Utilita: smart pay as you go, checked 2026-11-05. | Flexible Octopus in London |
| Smart E7Time of use | Pay as you go with a cheaper night rate, which Utilita says suits home EV charging. Utilita: smart pay as you go, checked 2026-11-05. | Octopus Go in London |
| POWER UPRewards | Temporary credit of up to £25 per fuel through the app when your balance is under £10, repaid through later top-ups. Utilita: POWER UP, checked 2026-11-05. | No direct equivalent |
| Utilita SEGExport | 3p/kWh; you do not need Utilita supply. Utilita: our schemes, checked 2026-11-05. | Outgoing Octopus in London |
Octopus is likely the better fit if…
You can pay by Direct Debit
Direct Debit tariffs are usually cheaper than pay as you go, and Octopus has a far wider range.
You have an EV, solar or heat pump
Utilita has no specialist tariffs and pays 3p for export.
Utilita is likely the better fit if…
You want to stay on pay as you go with in-person help
Utilita’s Energy Hubs and prepayment credit options are built for that.
You use very little energy
With no standing charge, low use can cost less on Smart Energy.
Switching from Utilita to Octopus
- Check whether you owe money on your meter. Prepayment customers with up to £500 debt per fuel can usually still switch, with the debt moving to the new supplier.
- Get an Octopus quote and pick a tariff. Octopus tells Utilita you are leaving, so there is nothing to cancel yourself.
- The switch completes within five working days under the Energy Switch Guarantee, and you have 14 days to change your mind. Your supply never goes off.
- Send an opening meter reading when Octopus asks. It accepts one from five days before your supply start date to five days after. Octopus tries to read a smart meter it can connect to automatically, but may still ask you for the first readings.
- Once the opening reading is agreed, Utilita sends a final bill. Octopus says suppliers should send it within six weeks, and refund any credit within two weeks of that bill.
- Moving from pay as you go to Direct Debit can need a credit check and a change of meter mode; Octopus can usually switch a smart meter remotely.
Before you switch
- Compare the full annual cost (unit rates plus 365 days of standing charge), not just the headline off-peak rate.
- Check exit fees on your current fixed tariff. Switching in the last 49 days of a fix is fee-free under Ofgem rules.
- Top up enough to cover the switch period so you do not run out before the change.
The full timeline is in how to switch to Octopus.
Our verdict
If you can move to Direct Debit, Octopus is very likely cheaper and better rated.
If you need to stay on pay as you go, compare Utilita’s prepayment rates with Octopus’s, and weigh Utilita’s in-person support against its weaker service scores.
Octopus vs Utilita: questions people ask
Can I switch from Utilita if I owe money?
Usually yes. Under Ofgem’s debt assignment rules, prepayment customers with up to £500 of debt per fuel can switch and take the debt with them.
Does Utilita offer Direct Debit?
Utilita says it offers Direct Debit tariffs as well as pay as you go, though it sold more than 40,000 of its credit customers to EDF in 2025.
Is pay as you go more expensive?
Prepayment has its own cap, and Direct Debit tariffs are usually cheaper. Utilita’s Smart Energy has no standing charge, which can help very low users.
Will my supply be cut off when I switch?
No. The same wires, pipes and meter carry on supplying you; only the company billing you changes. Under the Energy Switch Guarantee a switch completes within five working days.
Will my smart meter still work after switching to Octopus?
Second-generation (SMETS2) smart meters keep working in smart mode with any supplier. Older SMETS1 meters have mostly been moved onto the national network; if yours stops sending readings, Octopus can check or replace it. Smart tariffs need a meter sending half-hourly readings.
Where do the tariff prices on this page come from?
Each month we collect quotes for every tariff both suppliers sell, for the same address, usage and payment method, so the unit rates, standing charges and annual costs compare like for like. Octopus rates for your region are read live from Octopus’s published tariffs. Smart and EV tariffs that are not in the quotes are shown with their published rates and the date we checked them.
Other supplier comparisons
Utilita and industry sources
- Utilita: smart pay as you go — checked 2026-11-05.
- Utilita: POWER UP — checked 2026-11-05.
- Utilita: our schemes — checked 2026-11-05.
- Utilita: sale of credit customers to EDF — checked 2026-11-05.
- Ofgem: Utilita Warm Home Discount redress — checked 2026-11-05.
- Ofgem: investigation into Utilita prepayment practices — checked 2026-11-05.
- Ofgem: switching with prepayment debt — checked 2026-11-05.
- Ofgem: energy price cap — checked 2026-11-05.
- Ofgem: price cap unit rates and standing charges — checked 2026-11-05.
- Energy UK: Energy Switch Guarantee — checked 2026-11-05.
- Octopus: what happens if I’m away when you need a meter reading? — checked 2026-11-14.
- Octopus: what happens if I have a smart meter? — checked 2026-11-14.
- Octopus: how handover meter readings work when you switch — checked 2026-11-14.
- Citizens Advice: compare energy suppliers’ customer service — checked 2026-11-05.
- Which?: energy companies survey results — checked 2026-11-05.
- Cornwall Insight: supplier market shares after the E.ON–OVO deal — checked 2026-11-05.
- Octopus: Intelligent Octopus Go — checked 2026-11-05.
- Octopus: Outgoing Octopus — checked 2026-11-15.
- Octopus: Intelligent Octopus Flux — checked 2026-11-15.
- Octopus: Octoplus and Saving Sessions — checked 2026-11-05.
- Ofgem: Octopus pays £1.5m over prepayment billing errors — checked 2026-11-05.
Primary sources
- Energy price cap and standing charges explained — Ofgem; checked 2026-11-14. What the cap covers, how it is calculated, and why it is not a household bill limit. The cap is the most a supplier can charge for a unit of energy and standing charge together; suppliers set each tariff’s rates; it protects standard variable tariffs, not fixed tariffs; built from wholesale, network, policy, operating and other costs; set every three months.
- Domestic energy supply terms and conditions — Octopus Energy; checked 2026-11-14. General domestic tariff, meter, pricing, switching and referral terms. Updated 20 October 2026: prices do not change during a fixed rate tariff; reasonable notice of changes not to the customer’s advantage, including higher charges or a smart-tariff formula change, with the right to switch tariff or supplier without penalty. Checked 14 November 2026, section 5 (rights of cancellation): you may cancel by email or on the website within 14 days of submitting your application (the cooling-off period); if you cancel in that time you pay for supply from the Supply Start Date until your new contract starts, Octopus cannot stop you switching elsewhere and cannot charge exit fees; no exit fee in the final 49 days of a contract; after the supply date you can take a new Octopus contract, an equivalent contract with your previous supplier, or another supplier, and after 15 working days without action you move to a Deemed Contract. Clause 8.9: Octopus will not try to recover energy charges older than 12 months unless it already tried to, or you behaved obstructively or unreasonably. Clause 18: complaints follow octopus.energy/unhappy; after a deadlock letter or eight weeks you can refer the issue to the Energy Ombudsman.
- Octopus tariffs for electric cars — Octopus Energy; checked 2026-08-27. Current EV tariff choices, charging windows, smart-meter and device-compatibility requirements.
- Switch your home energy supplier — Ofgem; checked 2026-11-14. The 14-day cancellation right, the five-working-day switch deadline (with compensation from the new supplier if missed) and the 28-day debt rule. What a new supplier needs (postcode, current supplier and tariff, unit rate, yearly usage), and that the new supplier says when it will switch you. Moving home: you can choose a new tariff or supplier after moving in; renters who pay the bills can switch but should check the rental agreement and tell the landlord where required. Checked 14 November 2026: “If you change your mind, you can cancel your switch within 14 days.” Debts under 28 days old go on the final bill. If you are switched without permission, contact your old supplier: compensation is due and they have 21 working days to switch you back.